Friday, January 13, 2023

Non-compete clauses

Recently the FTC has proposed a ban on most non-compete clauses. This is a great idea, if this ban gets enacted the US stands to benefits in multiple ways including, increased worker mobility, increased innovation, increased growth, and increased market competition.

Silicon Valley
The lack of enforcement of non-complete causes in California is one of the factors that have helped to create a vibrant technology sector in that state. Non-compete clauses are a method for employers to reduce the competition by making it hard to poach and recruit talent. Without non-competes start-ups in California are able to grow and thrive in the shadow of giant technology companies because they are able to better execute on their roadmaps and strategy. Organizations such as Zoom have been able to thrive in California by identifying a need in the market not met by larger technology companies. Large technology companies have been sued by the Federal government for illegally preventing employees from getting offers from competing firms. For example, Steve Jobs was sued by the Feds for a gentlemen's agreement with one of the founders at Google to stop the organization from poaching talent away from Apple.

Abuses of Non-complete clauses
Non-compete clauses have also been abused by employees by using overly broad language that prevents employees from leaving the firm, or going to the competition. For example, in healthcare non-complete clauses often will dictate a geographical radius. In dense metropolitans, such as New York or LA, a non-complete clause of 25 miles means you'll essentially need to find another job in another city. 25 miles can mean a 2 hour commuting radius in large crowded cities with traffic.

Non-complete clauses are un-American
Non-complete clauses go against the ideas of America. The US should be a nation that encourages competition, entrepreneurship, free markets, and the ability for employees to freely move if they find better opportunities elsewhere. The rise of non-complete clauses is allowing for many larger well-resourced organizations to reduce competition and continue their rent-seeking behavior. The continuation of this will reduce the economic growth of the country, and the limit opportunities of employees. 

References: 

https://money.cnn.com/2014/08/11/technology/silicon-valley-poaching-case/

No comments:

Post a Comment